Manager: Graham Westley
Season Numbers: P42, W22, D14, L6, F65, A52, Diff +13, Points 72
Final Position: 5th
Final – Carlisle United Vs. Stevenage Borough FC at the Brittania Stadium
Eventual Play-off winners are Carlisle United, beating Stevenage Borough FC 1-0.
Carlisle United 1 – 0 Stevenage Borough FC
Saturday 14th May 2005
| Murphy (23) | |
| Attendance: 13,422 |
 |
 |
| Manager: Paul Simpson | Manager: Graham Westley |
| Team Sheet | Team Sheet |
| 01 Glennon | 01 Julian |
| 03 Cowan | 02 Warner  |
| 06 Gray | 05 Goodliffe (Weatherstone – 81) |
| 21 Livesey | 06 Laker (Boyd – 52) |
| 16 Beharall | 25 Henry |
| 17 Lumsdon | 15 Bulman |
| 07 McGill |
33 Gregory |
| 08 Billy | 07 Brady |
| 04 Murphy |
09 Maamria |
| 25 Murray (Vieira – 71) |
37 Elding |
| 09 Holmes (Hawley – 86) | 27 Stamp (Nurse – 66) |
| Substitutes | Substitutes |
| 20 Westwood | 17 Westhead |
| 02 Arniston | 04 Quinn |
| 28 Murray | 23 Weatherstone |
| 23 Vieira | 21 Boyd |
| 19 Hawley | 20 Nurse |
Semi-Final – Hereford United Vs. Stevenage Borough FC
Stevenage Borough FC progress to final, winning 2-1 on aggregate.
Hereford United 0 – 1 Stevenage Borough FC
Friday 6th May 2005
| Maamria (68) | |
| Attendance: 6,862 |
 |
|
| Manager: Graham Turner | Manager: Graham Westley |
| Team Sheet | Team Sheet |
| Mawson | Julian |
| Green | Warner |
| Mkandawire | Goodliffe |
| Tretton | Henry |
| Robinson | Laker |
| Daniel Williams | Brady |
| Hyde | Maamria |
| Stanley | Bulman |
| Purdie | Gregory |
| Carey-Bartram | Elding |
| Stansfield | Stamp |
| Substitutes | Substitutes |
| Travis | Westhead |
| James | Quinn |
| Pitman | Hocking |
| Scott | Nurse |
| Leroy Williams | Boyd |
Stevenage Borough FC 1 – 1 Hereford United
Monday 2nd May 2005
| Maamria (87) | Carey-Bertram (74) |
| Attendance: 6,520 |
|
|
| Manager: Graham Westley | Manager: Graham Turner |
| Team Sheet | Team Sheet |
| Julian | Mawson |
| Warner | Green |
| Goodliffe | Tretton |
| Henry | Mkandawire |
| Gregory | Robinson |
| Brady | Travis (Daniel Williams – 80) |
| Maamria | Stanley |
| Bulman | Pitman |
| Nurse (Boyd – 58) | Purdie |
| Stamp | Mills (Carey-Bartram – 66) |
| Elding |
Stansfield (James – 90) |
| Substitutes | Substitutes |
| Westhead | Leroy Williams |
| Quinn | Scott |
| Laker | Daniel Williams |
| Hocking | Carey-Bartram |
| Boyd | James |
